Colonials In The Pros
| Player | Year | Professional Team (League) | |
| Neil Shaffer |
2011 |
Pittsburgh Riverhounds (USL Pro Division) | |
| Ryan Zabinski |
2008 |
Pittsburgh Riverhounds (USL Second Division) | |
| Jacek Przednowek |
2008 |
New Jersey Ironmen (Major Indoor Soccer League) Pittsburgh Riverhounds (USL Second Division) |
|
| Allan Brown |
2007 |
Pittsburgh Riverhounds (USL Second Division) | |
| Jason Pelletier |
2007 |
Harrisburg City Islanders (USL Second Division) |  |
| Joe Di Buono | Polonia Warszawa (Polish First Division) Milwaukee Wave (Major Indoor Soccer League) Montreal Impact (USL First Division) Trois-Rivieres (Canadian Soccer League) |
 |
|
| Said Ali | 2004 |
Pittsburgh Riverhounds (USL First Division) |
 |
| Danny Anderson | 2003 | Sunnana FC (Damallsvenskan) |  |
| Jamie Dodds | 2003 | Toronto Lynx (USL First Division) |  |
| Rhian Dodds | 2003 | Kilmarnock F.C. (Scottish Premier League) |  |
| Matt Henson | 2002 | Northern Virginia Royals (USL Pro League) |  |
| Che Pitt | 2000 | Pittsburgh Stingers (Continental Indoor Soccer League) | |
| Steve Bell | 1997 | Washington Warthogs (Continental Indoor Soccer League) Tampa Mutiny (Major League Soccer) Pittsburgh Riverhounds (USL First Division) |
|
| Musa Shannon | 1997 | Tampa Bay Mutiny (Major League Soccer) Colorado Rapids (Major League Soccer) Maritimo (Portuguese Superliga) Nanchang Bayi Hengyuan FC (Chinese Football Association Jia League) Vancouver Whitecaps (USL) |
 |
| Chris Hultquist | 1996 | Reading Rage (USL Developmental League) Harrisburg Heat (Major Indoor Soccer League) |
|
| Kert Mease | 1996 | Washington Warthogs (Continental Indoor Soccer League) | |
| Troy Fabiano | 1994 | Pittsburgh Stingers (Continental Indoor Soccer League) Milwaukee Wave (Major Indoor Soccer League) Milwaukee Rampage (United States Indoor Soccer League) |
|
| Roman Kuropas | 1994 | (CISL) | |
| Doug Petras | 1994 | Tampa Bay Mutiny (Major League Soccer) Harrisburg Heat (Major Indoor Soccer League) |
|
| Todd Shulenberger | 1994 | Canton Invaders (National Professional Soccer League) | |
| David Moxom | Milwaukee Wave (Major Indoor Soccer League) | ||
| Fabrizio Mosactiello | Pittsburgh Riverhounds (USL First Division) |
